Licensed Lawyer in the Kingdom of Saudi Arabia | License No. 40462 | Practicing since 2013
Licensed Lawyer | License 40462 | Since 2013
Lack of criminal intent in Saudi Arabia: legal documents, a magnifying glass and scales of justice

Lack of Criminal Intent in Saudi Arabia: What It Means for Your Case

Lawyer Mohammed Al-Dosari — licensed to practise law in Saudi Arabia, licence no. 40462. The licensing and professional membership information is available to verify the website owner’s identity.

Last updated and legal sources checked: 21 November 2026.

Lack of criminal intent in Saudi Arabia can be relevant if you are accused of using a forged document but say you received it as genuine. Proving that you submitted the document does not, by itself, answer what you knew when you used it.

This guide explains the difference between denying the act and disputing knowledge of its true nature. It shows what to look for in messages, reports and records, how that may affect conviction, and why the same outcome does not automatically determine a compensation claim.

Quick answer: If an offence requires knowledge, deliberate conduct or a particular purpose, a conviction requires that element to be established. A lack of criminal intent argument may therefore lead to acquittal of the offence charged. It does not automatically decide another possible classification or a compensation claim: each has its own requirements and evidence.

When is criminal intent absent?

Criminal intent is absent when the knowledge, intention or purpose required for the offence is missing. Deliberately submitting a document, for example, is different from knowing that it is forged. To assess your position, identify the requirement in the relevant provision, then examine what you knew at the time and the evidence of that knowledge.

Knowledge, intention and a specific purpose

Knowledge means what you knew when the incident occurred, such as knowing that a document was forged. Intention concerns deliberately carrying out the act itself, such as submitting it. A specific purpose is an additional aim required by a particular provision, such as using an expired power of attorney to suggest that it remains valid.

That is why the precise charge matters. Article 1 of the Saudi law governing forgery offences connects forgery with bad faith and an intention to use the forged item. Article 19 addresses using a forged item with knowledge of its forgery. Creating a forged document and submitting one you did not prepare raise different questions.

How is evidence of intent examined in a Saudi criminal case?

Article 3 of the Law of Criminal Procedure published by the Ministry of Justice provides that a criminal penalty requires a conviction following trial. Where the accused denies the charge or does not answer, Article 162 requires the court to examine the evidence. Each party may also question the other party’s witnesses and evidence with the court’s permission.

When presenting a lack of criminal intent argument, identify the disputed information. Did you receive a warning about the forgery, and was it before or after use? Provide messages or records supporting your explanation and address the evidence against it. This does not mean that you must disprove every theoretical possibility of guilt.

Lack of criminal intent, denial of the act and insufficient evidence

“I did not submit this document” is different from “I submitted it, but did not know it was forged”. The first position raises questions about the act and who carried it out. The second focuses on what you knew when you submitted it. Use the table to identify which issue needs an answer.

IssueCentral questionWhat needs examination?
Denying the actDid I carry out the act at all?Check whether the act occurred and who performed it.
Attribution not establishedDoes the evidence establish that I carried it out?Examine the signature, account and usage records, rather than the account holder’s name alone.
Lack of criminal intentDid I know the relevant facts or have the purpose required for this offence?Review the information you received and what you said and did at the time.
Insufficient evidenceWhich element of the charge remains insufficiently established?Identify whether the gap concerns the act, its attribution or intent.

More than one issue may arise in the same file. State what you accept, what you deny and what you discuss on an assumed basis. This makes the defence easier to follow and avoids presenting conflicting accounts without explaining their relationship.

7 evidence checks for a lack of criminal intent argument

Use these seven questions when reviewing a charge or preparing documents for your lawyer. The aim is to identify the disagreement, the relevant evidence and the missing information, rather than relying on “I did not intend it” without explaining what supports that account.

1. What knowledge or intention does the charge require?

Read the offence named in the allegation and the provision relied upon. For using a forged document, ask what establishes knowledge of the forgery. For creating the forgery, examine the requirements concerning alteration of the truth, bad faith and intended use. This identifies the question the case file needs to answer.

2. Does the evidence establish the act, knowledge, or both?

If the allegation relies on a delivery receipt or transmission log, ask whether it establishes submission alone or also contains evidence of knowledge of the forgery. Knowledge may be inferred from conduct and its circumstances, but the connection needs explanation; simply referring to the existence of the receipt does not explain that reasoning.

3. When did the person receive the relevant information?

Write down when you received the document, submitted it and were warned about the forgery. A warning received afterwards does not, by itself, establish earlier knowledge. If there was another use after a warning, examine what the warning said and proof that it reached you. Identify the particular use that is being charged.

4. Does the provision require an additional purpose?

Some offences require a particular aim as well as knowledge. Article 17 of the forgery law concerns use of an expired judgment, judicial order or power of attorney. Its requirements include knowledge of expiry, an intention to suggest continuing validity, and a resulting establishment or loss of a right, or harm to another. Examine those requirements together.

5. What was each person’s role where several people are accused?

Map the work process: who created the document, reviewed it, sent it and submitted it? Then identify the information available to each person. A manager’s signature and an employee’s submission do not, on their own, explain whether both knew the same facts. Examine each person’s role and the evidence relating to them.

6. Have messages and technical reports been read in full?

Obtain the complete conversation and its attachments, and identify the question answered by the technical report. A signature report may establish that a signature is yours without examining what you knew about the document’s contents. Read the finding within its actual scope, then look for evidence connecting it to knowledge or intention.

7. Does the explanation withstand contrary evidence?

Examine what may weaken your explanation, including an earlier warning, clear instructions or inconsistent statements. Is there a fact that explains the inconsistency, and evidence supporting it? Reviewing favourable and unfavourable facts helps you assess the argument realistically and identify points that need attention before it is presented.

What evidence may support a lack of criminal intent?

Evidence supporting a lack of criminal intent argument should answer a concrete question: what did you know, when did you know it, and what was your role? It may matter because it establishes when information reached you or whether it reached you at all. The table explains the use and limits of each type of evidence.

EvidenceReview questionLimit of the inference
Messages and instructionsDid you receive a warning or assurance of authenticity before use?Keep the surrounding messages and attachments, and check the sender’s identity and delivery.
Authorisations and approvalsWas this act authorised, and within what limits?An authorisation explains your powers but does not, by itself, prove or disprove knowledge of forgery.
Technical recordsWho accessed the system, when, and who sent the document?The account name alone does not explain the actual user’s identity or what they read.
Expert reportsDid the expert examine the signature, an alteration or the document’s creation date?Check the question put to the expert: the report may not examine the person’s knowledge.
Witness evidenceWhat did the witness personally see or hear?Distinguish hearing a warning about forgery from merely believing that the person knew.

If the disagreement is technical, first identify what you need to find out: who used the account, whether the file was changed after signature, or when an alteration occurred. Article 171 of the Law of Criminal Procedure allows court-appointed expertise and access by the parties to a copy of the report.

Practical worksheet: Prepare four fields for each disputed point: fact — supporting evidence — relevance to intent — what needs verification. For example: when did the warning arrive, which message establishes delivery, was it before or after use, and does receipt need verification? Keep originals and complete conversations. Mark missing information as unknown instead of assuming an answer.

If disputed knowledge or intention is part of an existing case, explore the firm’s legal assessment and court representation services to identify the scope of assistance appropriate to the stage of the proceedings.

Before responding to a criminal allegation, request a case assessment on WhatsApp to understand what the evidence shows about intent and the next step appropriate to your case.

Example: when knowledge of a forged document arose

This is a hypothetical example, not a reported court judgment. A person receives a certificate from an intermediary who assures them that it is genuine. They submit it to an organisation, which later says it is forged. For the first submission, examine the intermediary’s messages, the source and any earlier warning signs to assess what the person knew at the time.

If they submit the certificate again after being informed of the forgery, assess the second use separately. Whether the warning reached them, and what it said, now become important. The messages might also reveal earlier knowledge, so their assertion that they learned of the forgery later does not settle the issue.

Article 19 requires knowledge of the forgery when using the forged item. In this example, the key question for a lack of criminal intent argument is: did the person know of the forgery when they used the document, and what establishes that? The answer depends on the evidence, not on the example alone.

How can lack of criminal intent affect conviction and private claims?

If the intent required for the offence is not established, its elements are incomplete and a conviction for that offence cannot properly follow. That does not automatically reject a compensation claim or establish another offence. Separate the following three questions when assessing the effect on your case.

The offence as charged

Read the specific reason for acquittal: did the court find that the required knowledge or intention was absent, or that the evidence was insufficient to establish it? For example, a finding that knowledge of forgery was not proved does not mean that the court declared the document genuine.

Whether another legal classification needs examination

While the case is being heard, the court may examine whether another offence fits the facts and its requirements are met. Failure to prove intent for the first charge does not automatically establish an alternative offence or negligence. Those matters need an applicable legal basis and supporting evidence.

For an explanation of when the legal classification may change during trial and the right to respond, see the guide to changes to the legal classification of a criminal charge, which addresses that procedural issue separately.

Private rights and compensation

In this context, a private right claim concerns a personal remedy sought by the injured party, which may include compensation. Conviction and punishment are a separate question.

Articles 173 and 180 of the Law of Criminal Procedure require private claims to be decided whether the criminal judgment convicts or acquits. Article 180 permits the court to decide the criminal case and defer those claims if investigating them would delay resolution of the criminal proceedings.

If compensation is claimed, examine the basis of the claim, the alleged harm and its connection to your conduct. Take account of what the judgment has already decided about the incident and its attribution. Do not assume compensation is either due or refused simply because the intent argument succeeded.

Common mistakes when assessing the argument

  • Relying only on an assertion of good faith: explain what you knew, its source and the evidence of when the information reached you.
  • Confusing fault with intention: distinguish an allegation of deliberate conduct from alleged negligence, and examine the requirements of each.
  • Reading too much into a document: do not treat a signature report as proof of knowledge of every statement in the document without examining the other facts.
  • Ignoring contrary evidence: prepare an evidence-based explanation of warnings or messages that may contradict your account.
  • Generalising from another case: the charge, timing of knowledge and evidence may differ even when the cases have similar names.

Frequently asked questions about lack of criminal intent

Does having no personal benefit establish a lack of criminal intent?

Not by itself. An offence may require knowledge of the relevant facts or a particular purpose even where you make no personal gain. Check whether benefit is actually an element of the offence charged, then assess its absence alongside the other evidence.

Does admitting a signature also admit knowledge of the document's contents?

Admitting that a signature is yours concerns attribution of the signature. It does not automatically admit knowledge of forgery or every statement in the document. Your complete account and the circumstances of signing still matter: they may help explain what you knew when you signed.

Does returning money after discovery negate the earlier criminal intent?

Repayment does not automatically negate intent at the time of the act. Separate two questions: what did you know then, and what effect may later repayment have on harm, private rights or sentencing? The effect depends on the applicable law and the circumstances.

Does a clean record prove that criminal intent was absent?

Not on its own. A clean record describes your history, whereas intent is examined in the current incident. Messages, instructions and conduct relating to that incident remain relevant to what you knew and intended.

Is not knowing the law the same as not knowing a relevant fact?

No. “I did not know this carried a penalty” is different from “I did not know the document was forged”. The first concerns knowledge of the legal rule; the second concerns the document's true nature. Their effects depend on the applicable Sharia principles, law and circumstances.

Can a defence challenge both attribution of the act and criminal intent?

Both may be examined if your position is clear. Identify which facts you deny, then explain the argument about intent if the act is attributed to you. Distinguish analysis on an assumed basis from changing your factual account, so that the arguments do not appear contradictory.

Conclusion: connect intent to its evidence and timing

Assessing lack of criminal intent starts with three questions: what did you do, what did you know at the time, and what establishes it? Identify the intent required for the offence, then ask whether the messages, records and reports establish that element or leave a gap in proof.

Start by placing events in chronological order, matching each fact to its evidence and identifying what remains unknown. This helps you explain the disagreement clearly to a lawyer and understand its possible effect on conviction and private claims without expecting a guaranteed result.

Legal information: This guide concerns Saudi law in general. Applying it requires examination of the particular facts and documents; it does not guarantee a legal outcome.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *